thoughts about session 3 on 7/24 w/Dr. Dube
- This topic has 27 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 13 years ago by
Anonymous.
-
AuthorPosts
-
July 24, 2012 at 2:45 am #24850
Anonymous
GuestJust in case you want to have your kids sing the Chinese Dynasty song http://apwhlhs.blogspot.com/2009/10/chinese-dynasty-song.html
July 24, 2012 at 2:46 am #24851Anonymous
GuestI hate to bring up food, because it is not terribly important... But if you are a type 2 diabetic, you can't really eat fruit and muffins for breakfast and be conscious by lunch. If there is some way to get protein... and maybe starchier carbs....
July 24, 2012 at 3:04 am #24852Anonymous
GuestIt is interesting to have learned about the four leading philosophical schools of thought in China. I vaguely knew about Confucians and their philosophy but I have never heard of Mohist, Daoists or Legalists. Today, I am to participate in the debate as a Daoist. From what I have gathered Daoists are ancient hippies who may have created a cultural hero to base their philosophy off of. The ideology seems to be, no need to fix what is not broken. If people live a simplistic life in which they are content with what they had, there will be no problems...no worries. The principle behind this is to avoid arrogance, excess and extravagance. In this way, "The Way" or going with the flow of nature, would guide everyone to their purpose in life, naturally. This concept was like a breath of fresh air. In America we are implicitly taught to grab the bull by the horns. We are taught to go out and make our lives happen. No one preaches to be satisfied with your station in life. To be happy driving what your driving or living where your living. Everyone strives for more and more. This race for excess/greed creates evil and makes man in theory evil. Although, the concept in and of itself is very basic, it has some great points to consider.
July 24, 2012 at 5:36 am #24853Anonymous
GuestI am a nong, an honorable and industrious farmer, who works long hard days raising the food that sustains life and gives strength. All around me the world is in chaos. These evil times have been brought about by the dissipation of society. Weakness, selfishness, greed, and vanity have seduced the people and led them away from the true path. We must stop the foolishness and focus our efforts on building a strong state. We must be loyal to our strong and firm leader who rises to command through his accomplishments not his artful words. This leader must restore order with laws clearly written and understood. These laws will be enforced without exception by punishment and reward. A strong state must be ruled by a sage that does not rely on benevolence or the goodness of his subjects, instead he sees to it they are not allowed to do what is bad. Yesterday my kind beloved father broke the law knowingly. Though I feel deep anguish and wish in my heart that his misdeed could be undone, I must bow to the law. My father must accept his just punishment for exceptions to the law will eat away at the fabric of the state and order will descend into chaos.
July 24, 2012 at 5:47 am #24854Anonymous
GuestI am a Daoist. My father just broke the law. He iss a very good father. He must have needed to break the law in order to follow his own path - since there is not just one way to solve problems - or just one path to take. I accept differences between people. The State wants me to be fearful, but that is not my belief. Ishouldnot be fearful of the State. I will try to telll the leaders about his path and why he made the choices he made. If the sage still dows not understand my father's point of view, then we should get rid of the sage for he is not accepting of differences. We should respect each other's point of view.
July 24, 2012 at 6:05 am #24855Anonymous
GuestMy father has been a very good man - to everyone - all his life. Recently, however, he committed a transgression. Obviously, my father must have temporarily forgotten the basic tenent of Mohism - that we love everyone universally. He forgot that no one person should do anything that will only benefit themselves. Now, my Mohist brothers and sisters would say that my father should be punished. However, I strongly disagree with them for two reasons:
1. Mohists despise waste. Since my father has spent his entire life being a good man, and has only had one transgression, it would be a waste of time and effort to punish him.
2. Order ultimately rests with the ruler. The ruler must be aware of the people's intentions and activities. When he is, there is order. Since my father has always been a good man, but broke the law this one time, logic dictates that the fault lies with the ruler and not my father. It is the the ruler's fault because he
was obviously ignorant of my father's intentions and activities.July 24, 2012 at 6:22 am #24856Anonymous
GuestI believe laws cause oppression and don't believe that people need to be controlled. In addition, no action should be taken by me in what happened to my father because I have a strong belief that order will prevail.
July 24, 2012 at 6:24 am #24857Anonymous
GuestAs a Confucian, I shall be loyal to my father. If he feels that he should not be punished from breaking the law, I will not tell a soul. If he feels that he should be punished from his crime, I will abide his wishes. If he is caught and punished, I shall stay by his side and help take care of any of his responsibilities. I will not be resentful of my father's transgressions but maintain my loyalty and love of him.
July 24, 2012 at 6:42 am #24858Anonymous
GuestI am a Daoist. Yesterday, my kind father broke the law. He has been more than benevolent toward me and my family. Yet, I know he had knowledge of the law, and his willing actions violated the law. My father lost his way. The Dao organizes everything in life, and my father with his dissatisfaction of not being content decided to oppose the nature of things. Therefore, he disrupted the normality of the flow of nature. My father believed laws oppress the nature of Dao. Therefore, I will ask my Sage to guide my father once more by correcting him kindly, not injuring him, and enlightening him back to his contentment.
July 24, 2012 at 6:53 am #24859Anonymous
GuestAs a Confucian, I would need to honor my father as the benevolent leader of my family. As the choices he madde were for the advantage and benefit of his family, I cannot find fault ith him. I must honor and respect my father and stand by him and my family.
edited by mgeorge on 7/24/2012July 24, 2012 at 7:15 am #24860Anonymous
GuestAs a Confucius, I have been taught that my loyalty is to my father. I am not sure why he broke the law, but I will not question it, for I am to always honor my father. I am also to follow the five guidelines, which one of them is to respect my father as well; in that being if his wishes are for me to not say anything, then I will not, or vise versa. In all for me, my father and family come first, and I know that he cares about us too, therefore, I trust that he did what he needed to do in order to protect my family and I.
edited by dcontreras on 7/24/2012July 24, 2012 at 7:25 am #24861Anonymous
GuestHey Sabro,
Thanks for bringing up this issue.July 24, 2012 at 8:58 am #24862Anonymous
GuestOlympics in China
Here is the opening ceremony for the olympics:
In case any of you are interested on talking about the Olympics in your lesson plan
July 24, 2012 at 9:28 am #24863Anonymous
GuestI am a Moist. My father has been a good person his whole life and has loved not only me but mankind equally. His one crime should be punished but I believe our ruler will make it a fair and just punishment depending on the crime. I do not believe that his crime has overshadowed his long life of respecting all people and I do not believe our wise ruler will either.
July 24, 2012 at 9:51 am #24864clay dube
SpectatorHi Folks,
Appreciate the feedback on breakfast and apologize that we can't offer a full slate of choices for breakfast and lunch.I wish we had the capacity to do so, but cannot. There are restaurants (though only a few serve breakfast, one is McKay's which is adjacent to the hotel, there is also a Denny's at the Jefferson/McClintock intersection) which can meet individual needs more fully. I realize that this is less convenient, but apologize for our limited abilities in this area. For lunch and dinner, there are far more choices. You may also consider the Superior Supermarket that is in University Village.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.