Professor Yamashita's insights into the origins of Japanese culture were fascinating. As an English teacher, I'm not sure that all of the historical information would be topical in class, although I personally enjoyed it very much.
The one thing I may use are the literary excepts such as from The Tales of Genji. I thought the Professor's explaination of the different realms of male and female was interesting. The fact that this extended into the writings of men and women is of further interest. It would be interesting to consider the earliest novels in a world literature course. Were novels initially seen as a female pursuit?
This was an elucidating session. I found it amusing that Japan has continually, from its beginnings to the present, seems to have had a Napoleon complex. First in regard to China, then to the rest of the world. Until now, I did not know that Japan was a sort of colony of China's, then recognized in its own right as a coherent entity. I wonder what their relationship is at present? Does it have the same overtones despite Japan's attempts at controlling their neighbor during WWII? An interesting question I hope will be answered in our next session dealing with Japan.
My family has the remenents of a Samurai background, and there are stories that have been passed down describing these men. Most of them are not about the finer qualities of these warriors, rather their disreputable aspects. Still in that age of passive and probably aggressive invasion they were a necessary part of life. We have them today, but we politely call them our Marines, or Navy Seals, and laud them to the skies. How much of our lives are run by these people I can only guess at, but then as now it is substantial.
Students examining this age and ours are sure to see the connections in attitude of these entities, and should be warned of their excess. Our younger generations must be careful to treat these dogs of war with caution.
I enjoyed Professor Yamashita's lecture, but am not sure how to incorporate the information into my English curriculum. Perhaps tying in The Tale of Genji with some anime or manga (Avatar? The high degree of information almost makes me wish I taught History instead of English.
This might be interesting to use with an American Lit class to supplement things like A Farewell to Manzanar or Snow Falling on Cedars I am interested in ready this book and possibly using it in my classroom.
It's funny, but I also really enjoyed the topic of castles, as well. I think it was because I enjoyed trying to figure out why the castles were built in the styles and locations that they were and what those styles and locations said about the politics and warfare of the times.
The approach that Prof. Yamashita took, that of providing artifacts and puzzles and letting those drive the session, was fantastic. I am planning on incorporating that into my own teaching as my world history freshmen would love it. Actually, I already have done that to a certain extent. While studying the Industrial Revolution, I had my students do a gallery walk and they tried to determine what the different inventions that were developed during that period were intended to do. They were quite engaged, and it definitely made me realize that they enjoy hypothesizing as much as any of us do.
This is an interesting comment on the nature of history texts. I have found that even some high school texts avoid mentioning negative aspects of various cultures in order to avoid offending. I always try to highlight the characteristics that most people would term "positive" as well as those that most would term "negative" in every culture in an effort to discuss those things without stressing them with regard to any one particular culture. I think it is always interesting to review my own cultural bias when I learn about other civilizations, time periods, etc. I always think it's good to have students do this as well. Recognizing bias is a challenging thing to learn, but once students get it, they start seeing it everywhere.
In a not-as-related note: the seeming contradiction between the Japanese desire to keep the population "purely Japanese" and the welcoming of Chinese culture was really interesting. The political and social forces that combined to produce these movements must have been significant.
Another book that might work for your American Lit. class is Kenzaburo Oe's A Personal Matter. I actually liken it to Catcher in the Rye in its coming of age theme (or not coming of age, depending on how you look at these books). There are significant differences, but a junior class could definitely see the similarities.
There's a bio of Oe on the Nobel Prize website: http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/literature/laureates/1994/oe-bio.html
I enjoyed looking through the warrior codes-- I thought one code that addressed affairs was fascinating-- a code from Chosokabe-shi Okite in 1595 says that if someone has an affair, "Although it is obvious, unless the guilty pair kill themselves, both of them should be executed."
I thought it was really interesting that it says, "although it is obvious" I'm sure this language would elicit a response from our students!
I know some people who are teaching King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table to their students; I think that it could be very interesting to have students compare and contrast these Japanese warrior codes with the knights' code of chivalry.
-Karen
The thing that struck me the most about this session was the origins of the Japanese. Perhaps more interesting, was the fingerprint info... peoples from the north are more likely than not to have loops and arches, whereas peoples of the south have whorls or cicular markings as fingerprints! Facinating! but true?? I am tempted to meet japanese people just to see if the findings hold.
PS My friend from India told me that you can always tell whjat part on India certaoin people are from based on the darkness of their skin. Darker is south and lighter is north. Stereotype or geo/regional phenomenom?? You decide!
Also on an interesting Note, the tale of genji. How can a text be interpreted in so many ways? Well time plays a big role i'm sure, but what about interpretation by people? Simply opionins and interpretations can play a huge role in rediscovering or morphing a story. This would be an interesting topic to bring up in English class.
PS Final thought on the Samurai. Before this class I always thought they were always fighting battles. After this course, wow opportunistic business men with tons of land and wealth! Sure they must obey the Shogun and they must follow the book of coodes and corule with constables and stewards, but there does seem to be an awful lot of power and discretion when you are away from the Shogun! 😛
I have also heard about based on the darkness of the skin about Chinese people. One of the explanation was because of farming. I am not sure if it still true since there is less farming....
Discovered a web site that contains an interesting lesson plan on samurai life. It covers all aspects including the behavior code using primary source, literature, cultural differences between the stages of Japanese medieval life and all the history of the period. This site is essentially a student handout, and does refer to a number of visuals that aren't included, but can be gotten from Google images to show in power point or make into transparencies. Still I appreciated the organization which differs from the History Alive text I'm supposed to use. Perhaps the two can be integrated. Also this handout could be used as an extension or a way to differentiate for some more advanced students to use as a basis for a web search to dig deeper. If anyone has time to take a look to see what could be gained or modified I'd love to hear your thoughts.
Here's the site:http://www.colorado.edu/cas/tea/imagingjapan/medieval/medieval-M2-print.pdf
Since watching the movie "the Last Samurai", I do not know anything about it. Professor Yamashita talked about the codes of Samurai in general, and Clay posted a link specifically for each domain. These helped me to understand what they were expected to live up to. I also read something about Samurai's marriages. Their marriages were arranged based on their ranks with another Samurai family since they did not have time to meet females. However, Samurai was allowed to have a mistress outside of Samurai family, and maybe even divorce if the female did not produce offspring(s).
I think this is very interesting. It is like marriages in royal family. Now I have a question in my head, "Did they do this for pure ? or only for convenience since the Samurai live together in a village? "
It is understandable why people believe the stories over the facts all the time. Normally, when we watch movies, we assume it is somewhat true and easier to remember. However, Facts takes time to research, and most of us do not do that unless we are interested in that topic ...