Reply to Happy Surprise with You Jin's Pets

I also chose this story.  I think it is a great story to use whether it's used in Chinese or English.  I also have had students like this and it has caused me to be creative in my approach to these struggling students.  They may not be able to thrive in all areas of a subject, but it's when a teacher is able to find common ground and build trust with that student that they will listen and try.  'Pets' is a wonderful story and I'm happy that I can add it to arsenal of resources.